Finding a high-performance partner for AI search and GEO projects can be challenging unless you know the exact criteria to evaluate agencies with.
This short guide is for marketers and business owners that want to find a GEO agency with the capability to drive performance for your business.
Not sure where your brand currently stands in AI search? Get a free GEO visibility snapshot from the POLARIS AI Search team
Key criteria to evaluate a high-performance GEO partner in the UK
1. Proven GEO Case Studies
GEO Case studies are a proven way to determine that an agency has the expertise to drive real world performance for your brand.
A good GEO case study should demonstrate these 5 areas:
- Some understanding of the tactical strategy to target the right customers on the right platforms for specific use cases / needs
- Rationale around the choice of platform and how to increase visibility in it by working on the areas that are cited / sourced “behind the scenes”
- Improvements in AI visibility and share of voice for commercial topics and prompts, comparing this against competitors
- Increased number of mentions and citations across relevant AI platforms
- Evidence of an uplift in AI referral traffic, engagement and conversion
2. Sector Experience
Sector experience is an important consideration when choosing a GEO partner. Due to AI platforms interpretating, retrieving and recommending information differently for different industries, you want the agency to have a proven track record of driving performance within your sector.
An agency with relevant experience will understand the topics, terminology, buying behaviours and trusted sources that influence AI recommendations within your industry. They should be able to demonstrate this understanding through relevant case studies and how it translates into their GEO strategy.
Look for experience across industries such as:
- B2B
- SaaS & Tech
- Financial Services & Fintech
- Office Services & Supplies
3. Geo Framework
Whilst the overall structure seems similar in principle to SEO (technical SEO, on page SEO, and off page SEO), the specific work streams and requirements differ when it comes to GEO delivery.
Therefore, a high-performance GEO agency will have their own GEO framework that sits independently to SEO, and if compared side by side to a typical SEO framework, should easily be identified as being different.
This is critical as the application of an SEO framework or SEO deliverables such as EEAT or Schema alone will drive an increase in indexation and prompt visibility but to really drive high-performance other aspects need to be considered.
Ask the agency to provide their GEO Framework and their SEO framework so that you can review them to determine feasibility.
4. Understanding of the relationship between SEO and GEO
Just in the last month since producing this list, research from within the industry has shown that we must focus on BING and the SEO performance of a website in BING as one of the components of increasing visibility inside ChatGPT. Understanding the GEO and AI Search ecosystem is critical in being able to drive performance.
This type of knowledge and expertise requires learning at speed, and confidence to gain clarity. The right agency partner will be able to demonstrate this to you in conversations but also the strategy they employ. This alone is probably one of the top 3 most important criteria to driving high performance, rather than just mediocre visibility against the competition.
5. Understanding of Search Behaviour across ChatGPT and other AI LLMs
Depending on the sector of your business and target audience, not all AI LLMs will be relevant. For example, for a Martech business, Claude is a relevant target AI LLM as data shows that marketers use this platform in particular over ChatGPT.
Therefore, even though ChatGPT dominates AI Search with over 58% market share, an understanding of the user concentration behind each platform, and search behavioural patterns will also help to ensure targeting is as effective as possible. This will also directly impact the performance of your GEO project or AI Search campaign. The better the targeting of your prospective customers, the higher the performance the investment and campaign will drive.
6. Tools being utilised
Historical SEO platforms such as SEMRush have a GEO and AI Search reporting function, but it is a bolt on and doesn’t yet offer as much insight as GEO specific platforms. When evaluating a GEO and AI Search agency, asking them what tools they use for intelligence including competitor and topic/prompt analysis will help you to determine how effective they will be with the data they will source.
/ GEO First platforms include
/ Peec.ai
/ Searchable
/ WAIKAY
7. Reporting
Reporting is very challenging for an AI Search & GEO Campaign because data around search demand does not exist in the same way as it does for traditional SEO (keyword rankings & search volumes).
A good GEO & AI Search report will not only provide you with insight into the visibility of particular topics being targeted, but also the content that’s being cited by AI platforms and the competitors that are surfaced.
A good question to ask a potential GEO Agency is how their reporting has evolved over 2026, as the industry is still in its infancy and insights are still being learnt.
A good GEO report should include:
| Measurement | What to look for |
| AI Visibility | Brand mentions and visibility across target prompts |
| Share of Voice | Visibility against relevant competitors |
| Citations | Sources and websites referenced by AI platforms |
| Sentiment | How the brand is represented in AI responses |
| Prompt Performance | Visibility across priority topics and commercial queries |
| Referral Traffic | Sessions and engagement from AI platforms |
| Business Impact | Enquiries, conversions and assisted performance where measurable |
How we curated this list
We used the above criteria to evaluate leading GEO agencies in the UK that have a tried and tested approach to GEO performance.
The UKs highest performing AI Search & GEO optimisation agencies
1. POLARIS – A specialist GEO, AI search and SEO agency combining technical optimisation, AI-focused content, digital PR and visibility tracking to improve brand discoverability across traditional and AI-powered search platforms.
2. Gripped – A B2B digital marketing agency specialising in SaaS and technology businesses, combining SEO, content, paid media and demand generation to drive pipeline growth.
3. Kaizen – An integrated digital marketing agency bringing together SEO, GEO, digital PR and social media to help brands improve visibility across search engines, AI platforms and social channels.
4. ClickSlice – A performance-led SEO agency offering traditional SEO alongside GEO, AEO and LLM optimisation, with a focus on improving organic visibility and search performance.
5. Straight Up Search – An independent search marketing agency focused on SEO and organic visibility, with services spanning technical optimisation, content strategy and emerging AI search opportunities.
6. Distinctly – An independent digital marketing agency combining SEO, digital PR, content marketing and paid media to improve organic visibility and deliver measurable business growth.
7. Buried – A specialist search agency integrating GEO, SEO, digital PR and link building to strengthen brand authority and visibility across traditional search engines and AI platforms.
8. Footprint Digital – An independent digital marketing agency offering SEO, content marketing, paid media and AI search optimisation to improve online visibility and commercial performance.
9. Bubblegum Search – An independent search marketing agency combining SEO, content strategy, digital PR and AI visibility intelligence to help brands improve their presence across search engines and generative AI platforms.
10. FirstMotion – A specialist B2B growth agency focused on GEO and AI search strategy, combining audience intelligence, buyer journey analysis, content optimisation and digital PR to improve visibility and generate pipeline opportunities.
SETUP A DISCOVERY CALL FOR YOUR GEO GOALS WITH OUR EXPERTS TODAY
POLARIS is a specialist digital marketing agency with over 15 years of organic search experience, now extended into a dedicated AI Search and GEO practice. Our GEO programmes are built on strong technical SEO, content, and digital PR foundations, integrating entity optimisation, structured data, AI crawler accessibility, and citation building into a coherent programme rather than applying GEO tactics in isolation from the underlying organic search infrastructure.
See where your brand appears in AI answers
We run your category’s real prompts across ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews to show exactly where you’re cited, where competitors appear without you, and your Share of Citation baseline. Book an AI footprint audit to get your prioritised plan.









